Plum Creek Antiques offers a thoughtfully curated collection of rustic treasures and Americana — every item feels hand-picked, full of character, and deeply tied to Indiana’s rural past.

A Brown County Treasure Minutes from the 1891 Schoolhouse Inn

If you’re planning a stay at the 1891 Schoolhouse Inn, you’re already in the perfect spot to explore the charm of Brown County. Just a short scenic drive north of Nashville, Indiana, you’ll find one of our favorite local spots—Plum Creek Antiques in Beanblossom.

This cozy antique shop is tucked along Gatesville Road, about 10 to 15 minutes from the inn. Whether you’re a vintage enthusiast or just love discovering something unexpected, it’s well worth the trip.

You’ll find antique stoneware, cast-iron cookware, barn wood, fruit jars, old Model T and A truck parts, and other relics of Midwest history. The atmosphere is peaceful, the shopkeepers are friendly, and the selection changes just often enough to keep you coming back.

Why It Belongs on Your Brown County Itinerary

When you stay at the 1891 Schoolhouse Inn, you’re already surrounded by history—and Plum Creek Antiques is a natural fit. It’s the kind of place that invites you to slow down and explore, where browsing becomes part of your adventure.

You’ll enjoy the drive through scenic hills and farmland, and the shop itself is a quiet little surprise along the way. It makes a great stop on the way to or from downtown Nashville, and it pairs nicely with an afternoon of shopping or hiking in the area.

How to Get There

Plum Creek Antiques is located at 25 East Gatesville Road in Beanblossom, Indiana—just 6 miles north of Nashville. From the inn, take Highway 135 north, then turn onto Gatesville Road. The drive is peaceful and easy, and the destination is worth every mile.

Make a Day of It: Other Things to Do Nearby

Beanblossom has a lot to offer if you’re looking to turn your outing into a full-day experience. While you’re in the area, consider stopping by The Farmhouse Café & Tea Room for lunch, or head over to the Bill Monroe Music Park for live music and a dose of bluegrass history.

You can also swing back into downtown Nashville for a visit to local art galleries, restaurants, and boutique shops. Or head south to Brown County State Park to hike, take in the views, or just unwind in nature.

Tips for Visiting

Plum Creek is typically open only on weekends, but during October, you may find them open on weekdays as well. Since hours can vary, it’s always a good idea to call ahead.

Most of the items are affordably priced, and cash is often preferred. Don’t be afraid to ask about the history behind an item—many pieces have great stories, and the folks behind the counter are happy to share them.

A Local Favorite

Visitors often describe the shop as “small but well-curated,” and that really sums it up. It’s the kind of place where you might stumble upon a piece that feels like it was waiting just for you—a lantern, a crock, a hand-carved tool with decades of stories in its grain.

A Perfect Addition to Your Brown County Getaway

Plum Creek Antiques is more than a shop. It’s a reflection of the slow-paced, deeply rooted charm that makes Brown County special. When you stay at the 1891 Schoolhouse Inn, you’re just a short drive away from one of the most memorable little places in the region.

Pack a tote, bring your curiosity, and make time to explore. It’s the kind of stop that adds personality to your trip—and maybe a one-of-a-kind piece to your home.

Ready to plan your visit? Book your stay today at My Brown County Vacation rentals and make Plum Creek Antiques part of your Brown County experience.